Since being back in the States I’ve had the opportunity that most people in full-time ministry don’t get; the chance to attend a different church each week. Now I know the classic pastoral response is to find a church “home” and get plugged in. I think that will happen in the future, but right now going around and visiting friends in the ministry at the place they call home every Sunday.
This has helped bring me some perspective on a few of the “basics” that ministers sometimes forget; like what it feels like to be a first-time visitor, a nameless face in the back row, someone who after a long work week would rather Sunday be a day off rather then an action-packed work day.
Does this mean I won’t go back to ministry in the future? Not at all! I think this is just a great opportunity to gain some perspective on what a congregation is like.
There are two factors by which I judge (yes judge) a church:
1. The Cringe Factor. This is anything that makes one eye close in agony while the other one is wide open in disbelief that this is actually happening in the house of God. Some people don’t like that I have this “Cringe Factor,” but it’s not as bad as it seems. Sometimes large churches can make a person cringe, sometimes it’s small churches. It’s not just a wrong note that makes me cringe, it’s just a wrong attitude that one can sense in the service.
2. The Right Factor. This is the feeling that you get when it’s just “right.” The church doesn’t have to be huge with lots of lights or a great speaker; it just has to feel “right.”
A few things I’ve noticed over the last two months:
- As a first time visitor I had to walk about 2 blocks in the rain because the parking lots were SO packed. Normally this would make someone not feel welcomed and never want to go back (that’s what the “stats” say), but the service was so “right” that it didn’t matter.
- One of the “smaller” churches we went to was really one of the better services we went to.
- Bigger isn’t always better. If not for the preaching at the largest service (about 800 in the service, 2500 in the church), I would say it was just eh.
- Churches/pastors/greeters/leaders, if they are going to pray for anything, should always, ALWAYS ask for God to speak, show up and move during a service, rather then have a good show.

